Transformations: Montessori & Stage Theory
Trees start out small and then generally keep their form as they get progressively bigger and stronger. Children, however, change drastically as they develop. Think about the transformations that happen from a newborn baby to a running toddler to a nine-year-old playing soccer to an adolescent driving a car. They do not even seem like the same being as when they began.
Prior to the mid-1800s, people considered human development to be linear. A child was considered to be like a young adult who just got older and bigger, like a tree. However, the study of psychology changed the way we look at human development. Psychologists began to realize that humans pass through a sequence of distinct stages at different ages. This understanding of development as a progression was termed Stage Theory.
Origins of Stage Theory
Stage theories were popular during the time that Dr. Maria Montessori was developing her pedagogy. Stage theories take development and break it down into characteristically distinct stages assigned to specific ages. The theory assumes that certain characteristics are going to be developed during each stage. Stage theory also postulates that because certain aspects of development are supposed to happen during a particular stage, there are some innate powers available to individuals during that time. Those innate powers help individuals acquire the developmental progress for that stage. Stage theories also imply that there is also going to be a sequence to development and that stages cannot be skipped. The outcomes of one stage become the foundation for the following stage.
Examples of Stage Theory
Several of Dr. Montessori’s predecessors, contemporaries, and students were likely influencing her work, and likely she was influencing theirs. Some key individuals include:
Jean-Jacque Rousseau, of Geneva, postulated a stage theory of development in his book, Emile (1762). Rousseau presented an idealized “natural man” who was uncorrupted by modern society. He also proposed a system of education formulated around a specific pedagogy for each stage of life and the characteristics of each stage of human development.
Sigmund Freud, of Austria, constructed a stage theory to describe the psychosexual development of humans. He described personality development as a series of stages and he believed that early childhood was the most important stage, with the individual’s personality being formed by about the age of five.
Erik Erikson, a German American who also earned a Montessori certificate, proposed a theory describing eight distinct stages of development. He felt that how individuals face the challenge in each stage determined the outcome of the stage. He focused on the psychosocial aspects of humans.
Jean Piaget, of Switzerland, also developed a stage theory that described the psychosocial aspects of humans. Piaget proposed that children go through four stages of cognitive development.
Lawrence Kohlberg, an American, was likely influenced by Piaget but focused on moral reasoning and the stages of moral development.
Gail Sheehy, author, and journalist has documented stages of adult life and has authored numerous books about stages, or what she calls passages (e.g., Passages: Predictable Crises of Adult Life).
Montessori’s Model: Planes of Development
Dr. Montessori did not develop stage theory but used this construct to help her better understand human development. What is different about Montessori’s stage theory is that it does not focus on a particular aspect of development. Her framework is holistic and incorporates physical, social, emotional, and intellectual development.
Dr. Montessori called her holistic stage theory the “planes of development.” Each plane is a distinct psychological learning period that spans about six years: birth to six, six to twelve, twelve to eighteen, and eighteen to twenty-four. Each plane is characterized by the physical and psychological changes that take place, as well as the environmental needs of each plane.
Dr. Montessori observed how the differences between each plane were so dramatic that the shift from one stage of development to the next was metamorphic. The same individual emerges from each plane, unrecognizable from the individual they were when they entered the previous plane.
Characteristics of the Planes of Development
Dr. Montessori passionately describes how education needs to follow these periods of development, to be sensitive to the rebirth that is happening for each individual child.
“The child does not grow in a uniform way day by day, at the same rate. In growth there are crises, somewhat like the metamorphosis of the insects…. In fact, it is the child himself who will be the guide of education.” – Dr. Maria Montessori, The Four Planes of Education
The metamorphosis that happens in different periods of growth demonstrates the unique needs, behaviors, and characteristics of children at different ages.
Since each developmental plane is distinct, it follows that the needs of individuals will also be distinct. Plus, at each stage children require different things from their environment. Furthermore, the successful completion of one phase sets individuals up for successful development in the next stage.
Dr. Montessori was an optimist and did not see this need for successful completion of each stage as being fatalistic. She thought that missed opportunities within a plane of development could be overcome with conscious effort and work. Granted, this development would not happen as easily as if happened at the right time, but Dr. Montessori thought that if individuals applied themselves and worked, they could overcome some of these obstacles. The work accomplished outside of an intended plane, however, would never be as fully integrated as if it had happened during its intended time.
Montessori’s Unique Approach
When Dr. Montessori developed her theory on the planes of development, she did not describe development in a culturally specific context or time. She described universal aspects of human development in all cultures.
Two other aspects set Montessori’s work apart from stage theory. One was that she focused on what is normal development for children rather than what is abnormal. Also, she not only articulated her theory of the planes of development but then went a step further and developed an educational approach that supported it.
In Montessori, everything we do for children–all our methods, materials, and environments–is reflective of our understanding of the planes of development. We understand the needs of children in the distinct stages of their development and know we have a profound responsibility to support those needs.